What’s in Your Personnel File? New York Gives Employees the Right to Find Out

A performance review can shape a promotion. A written warning can justify a termination. Yet employees often have little chance to see the records behind those decisions. New York’s new personnel records law will give them that chance, and it will require employers to rethink how they maintain, share, and correct employment records.
On September 9, 2026, Governor Kathy Hochul signed Senate Bill S3460 into law, adding Section 210-b to the New York Labor Law. The law takes effect November 8, 2026. It covers current and former employees and applies broadly to private and public employers, with no minimum number of employees. [1]
What counts as a personnel record under New York’s new law?
The definition turns on what a record does. A record qualifies if it identifies an employee and is used, has been used, or may be used in connection with employment qualifications, promotion, transfer, additional compensation, or discipline. Covered materials include applications and resumes, compensation information, performance evaluations, written warnings, probationary periods, signed waivers, termination notices, and other disciplinary documents. Records held by a vendor under a contract to keep or supply personnel records are covered as well.
Employers should therefore take inventory of where these records are kept. A central HR folder may be only the starting point. A manager’s own performance notes, or records held by an outside HR provider, may fall within the statutory definition and belong in the personnel record. The statute may also be read to require an employer that does not now maintain such records to create and keep them.
How quickly must New York employers provide a copy of a personnel file?
Once an employee submits a written request, the employer must provide a free copy of the personnel record within five business days. Employers need not allow more than two reviews per calendar year. But, as discussed below, when an employer places negative information in an employee’s file, a request for the full file does not count toward that limit.
Employers would be wise to designate someone to receive requests, name a backup, and confirm that outside providers can retrieve records quickly. Employees should submit dated written requests and keep a copy. The statute does not require employees to sue or to explain why they want their records.
When must employers notify employees about negative information in their file?
Employers must notify an employee within ten days after placing information in the personnel record that is, has been, or may be used to negatively affect employment qualifications, promotion, transfer, additional compensation, or the possibility of discipline. Note the difference: the production deadline runs in business days, but this deadline runs in calendar days. [2]
A written warning is the obvious example. A negative evaluation used to deny a bonus may qualify as well. HR should build notice into the documentation process and keep proof of delivery. Because the statute does not prescribe a form of notice, a consistent written notice is the sensible course. Employees, for their part, should read these notices promptly and request the underlying records when something is unclear.
Can employees dispute or respond to information in their personnel file?
An employee and employer may agree to correct or remove disputed information. If they cannot agree, the employee may submit a written statement explaining their position, which must become part of the personnel record. That statement must accompany the disputed information when it is sent to a third party for as long as the original information remains in the file. [3]
A disagreement does not automatically require an employer to withdraw a warning or reverse an evaluation. Employees should identify specific inaccuracies and the facts that support them. Employers should evaluate correction requests on the merits and keep rebuttals attached to the disputed documents. Where the employer knew or should have known that information was false, the law permits the employee to seek expungement through a collective bargaining agreement, other personnel procedures, or the courts. [3]
How long must New York employers keep personnel records?
The statute requires retention of the complete personnel record throughout employment and for three years after separation, without deletion or expungement, while separately permitting agreed corrections and removal. Employers should reconcile those provisions carefully before changing records. [3]
In our view, employers should consider keeping personnel records for at least six years after termination. New York wage claims generally carry a six-year statute of limitations under Labor Law Sections 198(3) and 663(3), and compensation histories, job descriptions, and other personnel documents may be essential to defending those claims. The new law’s three-year requirement is thus a floor, not a destruction date. This recommendation rests on New York law. Limitations periods under other wage and hour laws may differ, and litigation holds, tolling, or other legal requirements may call for longer preservation. [5]
Access has limits, too. The law excludes personal information about someone other than the requesting employee when disclosure would be a clearly unwarranted invasion of that person’s privacy. Employers should review responsive records with that in mind and seek legal advice on privileged and sensitive investigation materials, rather than reflexively releasing or withholding an entire investigation file. [2]
Who enforces the law, and what happens if an employer retaliates?
Section 210-b(8) prohibits discharge, threats, penalties, discrimination, and retaliation against employees who exercise their rights under the statute. It expressly covers immigration-related reports and threats involving employees or their family or household members. Managers should understand that requesting a file or submitting a rebuttal is protected conduct and must not count against the employee in later decisions. [3]
Section 210-b(7) assigns enforcement to the New York Attorney General and provides for fines of $500 to $2,500. As written, the statute does not appear to create a general private right of action, and its anti-retaliation provision does not include a separate damages remedy. There is one important qualification: Section 210-b(3) contemplates judicial proceedings to expunge information the employer knew or should have known was false. Other laws may also supply remedies. Employers therefore should not assume that AG enforcement shields them from employee litigation. [3]
The Governor’s approval memorandum identified ambiguities and noted an agreement with the Legislature to address them next session. The expected amendments would clarify that employers need not create personnel files or generate documents beyond the records they already keep, and would narrow the definition to records actually used in employment decisions. Those changes are not yet law. Employers should prepare for the November 8 effective date while watching for amendments. [4]
Employers should use the remaining time to map their records, set up request and notice procedures, train managers, and create a reliable way to attach employee responses to disputed documents. Unionized employers should also review their collective bargaining agreements, because the statute preserves those terms only if they provide at least substantially similar access. [3]
For employees, the new law offers a practical chance to understand the documents behind workplace decisions and to correct errors before those errors follow them into the next review, promotion discussion, or job search. For employers, accurate records and timely communication will become an even more important part of sound performance management.
To continue the conversation, reach out to David and Mariya at TheEmploymentStrategists@norris-law.com. In the meantime, stay tuned for more employment law developments through our blog and podcast.
This blog is not intended, and should not be taken, as legal advice or legal opinion on any specific facts or circumstances. The contents are intended for general information purposes only and you are urged to consult a lawyer concerning your own situation with any specific legal questions you may have. The content reflects the personal views and opinion of the participants.
Sources
[1] New York State Senate, S3460, bill status and legislative history (Chapter 293, Laws of 2026); S3460 § 2 (effective date). View source
[2] S3460 § 1, adding N.Y. Labor Law § 210-b(1) and (2) (definitions, access, and notice). View source
[3] S3460 § 1, adding N.Y. Labor Law § 210-b(3) through (8) (responses, retention, collective bargaining, enforcement, and retaliation). View source
[4] Cooley, October 13, 2026, reporting the Governor’s approval memorandum and anticipated chapter amendments. View source
[5] N.Y. Labor Law §§ 198(3) and 663(3) (six-year limitations periods for New York wage claims). § 198 § 663
