MENU Close
Close
  • Home
  • Services
  • Attorneys
  • Resources
  • News & Events
  • About Us
  • Contact Us
  • Join our Team
Search
Back
    Quick Links:
    Join Webinar
    Read News
    Our Location
    A
    Alternative Dispute ResolutionAntitrust & Trade RegulationAppellate Practice
    B
    Banking & Financial ServicesBankruptcy, Creditors’ Rights, and Financial RestructuringBeer LawBusiness Law
    C
    Cannabis LawConstruction LawCriminal Defense
    E
    Economic Development LawElder Care & Special Needs LawElectronic Discovery ("E-Discovery")Environmental LawEstate Planning and Administration & Wealth PreservationExecutive Compensation, Employment, ERISA, and Employee Benefits
    F
    Food, Beverage & HospitalityFranchise Law
    H
    Health Care & Life SciencesHealth Care ProvidersHigher EducationHospitals and Health Networks
    I
    ImmigrationInsurance CoverageIntellectual PropertyIntellectual Property Litigation, Arbitration, and Dispute ResolutionIntellectual Property Portfolio Strategy, Management & LicensingInternational BusinessInternet Law
    L
    Labor & EmploymentLiquor Law, Licensing, Manufacturing, and DistributionLitigation
    M
    Media LawMergers & AcquisitionsMunicipal Law
    N
    Non-Profit Law
    P
    Patent Preparation and ProsecutionPharmaceutical / Medical Devices / Pharma ServicesProducts and Consumer Liability DefenseProfessional LiabilityPublic Utilities
    R
    Real Estate, Finance, and Land Use
    S
    SecuritiesSolar Energy
    T
    TaxationTelecommunicationsTrademark & Copyright Protection & Enforcement
    V
    Venture Tech & Emerging Growth Companies
    W
    White Collar Investigations & DefenseWorkers’ Compensation
    • New Jersey
    • New York
    • Pennsylvania
    • Blogs
    • Articles
    • Podcasts
    • COVID-19 Resources
    • News
    • Events
    • Webinars
    • About Us
    • Delivering Value
    • Diversity & Inclusion
    • Meritas

    New Jersey

    400 Crossing Boulevard
    8th Floor
    Bridgewater, NJ 08807
    Phone:(908) 722-0700
    Fax:(908) 722-0755

    28 Valley Road
    Suite 1
    Montclair, NJ 07042

    New York

    7 Times Square
    21st Floor
    New York City, NY 10036
    Phone:(212) 808-0700
    Fax:(212) 808-0844

    Pennsylvania

    515 West Hamilton Street
    Suite 502
    Allentown, PA 18101
    Phone:(610) 391-1800
    Fax:(610) 391-1805

    • What sets us apart
    • Attorneys
    • Other Professionals
    • Professional Development
    • Non-Discrimination Policy

    Categories

    Copyright Copyright Infringement Copyright Licensing Copyright Office Copyright|Copyright Infringement|Intellectual Property Copyright|Intellectual Property Court Decisions Double Patenting>Same Invention Double Patenting>Terminal Disclaimers Drafting Patents Drafting Patents>Claims Drafting Patents>Claims>Written Description False Advertising Federal Circuit Food & Beverage General In The News Intellectual Property Labeling Lanham Act Legislation Licensing Navigating the Patent Office Navigating the Patent Office>Examiner Interviews Obviousness/Inventive Step>Prima Facie Obviousness Patent Patent Eligibility Privacy Right of Publicity Social Media Supreme Court Trade Dress Trademark Infringement Trademark Infringement|Trademark Registration|Trademarks Trademark Infringement|Trademarks Trademark Office Trademark Registration Trademark Registration|Trademarks Trademarks TTAB Uncategorized Unfair Competition
    Blogs > More Than Your Mark® > JACK DANIEL’S vs. BAD SPANIELS
    Member
    Jeanne Hamburg
    Visit Profile

    JACK DANIEL’S vs. BAD SPANIELS

    JACK DANIEL’S vs. BAD SPANIELS

    Can a whiskey maker stop production of a copycat pet toy marketing itself as dog poo?

    What are the First Amendment rights attaching to a parodic use of trade dress? And to what extent does the law allow the owner of a famous trade dress to stop production of a non-competing product that copies that trade dress (that is, the design and labels on a product package)? Those are two of the questions the Supreme Court will decide in Jack Daniel’s Properties, Inc. v. VIP Products, LLC. The case pits the owner of the trade dress of a liquor bottle labeled “JACK DANIEL’S Old No. 7 Brand Tennessee Sour Mash Whiskey” against a dog’s chew toy in the shape of a liquor bottle labeled “BAD SPANIELS Old No. 2 on your Tennessee Carpet.” Jack Daniel’s says its product is 40 percent alcohol by volume; Bad Spaniels claims to be “43 percent poo.” The products are shown below:

    Trademark infringement cases require the trademark owner to prove that consumers will likely be confused as to the trademark owner’s association, source, or sponsorship with respect to the infringing product. But trademark dilution cases allow owners of “famous” trademarks or trade dress – ones generally recognized by the vast majority of the public, whether or not they purchase the product—to make a case without proving a likelihood of consumer confusion. To do so, the owner may prove “blurring” via the trade dress’ association in consumers’ minds with more than just a single source (that is, some source other than the trademark owner). Alternatively the trademark owner may prove “dilution by tarnishment,” that is, that the infringer’s use of the trademark/trade dress establishes a negative association in consumers’ minds (such as, for example, associating Jack Daniel’s with dog poo).

    But to what extent does the owner of the accused product in this case have a First Amendment right to “express” the parodic content embodied in the chew toy? The Ninth Circuit found that First Amendment right trumped Jack Daniel’s claims for both trademark infringement and dilution. As to infringement, the Ninth Circuit found Jack Daniel’s had failed to establish that the defendant’s use of the Jack Daniel’s trade dress either (1) was not artistically relevant to the work (that is, the Black Spaniels bottle and its design and label); or (2) explicitly misleads consumers as to the source or content of that work. It also granted summary judgment to the defendant on Jack Daniel’s trademark dilution by tarnishment claim on the grounds that the defendant had used Jack Daniel’s trade dress and bottle design to convey a humorous message (and not merely to sell the Bad Spaniels product).

    In their amicus brief to the Supreme Court, producers of alcoholic beverages argue that commercial speech is less entitled to First Amendment protection than noncommercial artistic expression (the chew toy is being sold for profit). They further argue Bad Spaniels is marketed to children, thereby undermining the producers’ efforts to promote responsible drinking. Is the Bad Spaniels’ product entitled to the same First Amendment protection as noncommercial art work (such as Andy Warhol’s famous Campbell’s soup cans)? Like those in the liquor business, the American Intellectual Property Law Association says no---and that the Ninth Circuit’s ruling should be overturned. Stay tuned to find out what happens next.

    If you have any questions about trademark clearance, registration or enforcement (including litigation) please feel free to contact me at jhamburg@norris-law.com.

    Member
    Jeanne Hamburg
    Visit Profile

    Related Posts

    Around the World and Back Again: Tips for Global Brand Protection US Patent and Trademark Office Suspends Action on Trademarks Critical of Public Figures Hermés Wins on Metabirkins Cryptobags

    Share

    Tags

    #branding #trademark infringement #trademark law

    Similar Posts

    February 24, 2023
    Hermés Wins on Metabirkins Cryptobags
    Hermés Wins on Metabirkins Cryptobags
    August 6, 2021
    Capturing All the Dimensions: Intellectual Property Protection for 3-D Designs and 3-D Printing Methods
    Capturing All the Dimensions: Intellectual Property Protection for 3-D Designs and 3-D Printing Methods
    February 26, 2021
    Trade Dress Claims Involving Food Design and Packaging
    Trade Dress Claims Involving Food Design and Packaging

    Helpful links

    • About Us
    • News
    • Services
    • Blogs
    • Attorneys
    • Articles
    • (COVID-19)
    • Events
    • Join our Team
    Connect

    Connect with Us

    • LinkedIn
    • Facebook
    • Twitter
    • Instagram
    • Youtube

    Join our growing team

    We are looking for quality attorneys to help us do more for our clients. At Norris McLaughlin, each attorney has the same opportunity to succeed whether you’re at the beginning of a career or pinnacle of the profession.

    Learn More

    Subscribe to our content

    Receive timely legal information delivered to your inbox

    This field is for validation purposes and should be left unchanged.
    © , Norris McLaughlin, P.A., All Rights Reserved. Attorney Advertising.
    VIEW OUR DISCLAIMER,  TERMS OF USE,  AND PRIVACY POLICY

    We use cookies to ensure that we give you the best experience on our website. If you continue to use this site we will assume you consent to our cookie policy. Learn more