MENU Close
Close
  • Home
  • Services
  • Attorneys
  • Resources
  • News & Events
  • About Us
  • Contact Us
  • Join our Team
Search
Back
    Quick Links:
    Join Webinar
    Read News
    Our Location
    A
    Alternative Dispute ResolutionAntitrust & Trade RegulationAppellate Practice
    B
    Banking & Financial ServicesBankruptcy, Creditors’ Rights, and Financial RestructuringBeer LawBusiness Law
    C
    Cannabis LawConstruction LawCriminal Defense
    E
    Economic Development LawElder Care & Special Needs LawElectronic Discovery ("E-Discovery")Environmental LawEstate Planning and Administration & Wealth PreservationExecutive Compensation, Employment, ERISA, and Employee Benefits
    F
    Food, Beverage & HospitalityFranchise Law
    H
    Health Care & Life SciencesHealth Care ProvidersHigher EducationHospitals and Health Networks
    I
    ImmigrationInsurance CoverageIntellectual PropertyIntellectual Property Litigation, Arbitration, and Dispute ResolutionIntellectual Property Portfolio Strategy, Management & LicensingInternational BusinessInternet Law
    L
    Labor & EmploymentLiquor Law, Licensing, Manufacturing, and DistributionLitigation
    M
    Media LawMergers & AcquisitionsMunicipal Law
    N
    Non-Profit Law
    P
    Patent Preparation and ProsecutionPharmaceutical / Medical Devices / Pharma ServicesProducts and Consumer Liability DefenseProfessional LiabilityPublic Utilities
    R
    Real Estate, Finance, and Land Use
    S
    SecuritiesSolar Energy
    T
    TaxationTelecommunicationsTrademark & Copyright Protection & Enforcement
    V
    Venture Tech & Emerging Growth Companies
    W
    White Collar Investigations & DefenseWorkers’ Compensation
    • New Jersey
    • New York
    • Pennsylvania
    • Blogs
    • Articles
    • Podcasts
    • COVID-19 Resources
    • News
    • Events
    • Webinars
    • About Us
    • Delivering Value
    • Diversity & Inclusion
    • Meritas

    New Jersey

    400 Crossing Boulevard
    8th Floor
    Bridgewater, NJ 08807
    Phone:(908) 722-0700
    Fax:(908) 722-0755

    28 Valley Road
    Suite 1
    Montclair, NJ 07042

    New York

    7 Times Square
    21st Floor
    New York City, NY 10036
    Phone:(212) 808-0700
    Fax:(212) 808-0844

    Pennsylvania

    515 West Hamilton Street
    Suite 502
    Allentown, PA 18101
    Phone:(610) 391-1800
    Fax:(610) 391-1805

    • What sets us apart
    • Attorneys
    • Other Professionals
    • Professional Development
    • Non-Discrimination Policy

    Categories

    Anti-Trust/Trade Regulations Banking/Financial Services Business Operations Choice of Entity Compliance Corporate Finance/Securities Corporate Governance Economic Development Law Entity Formation Franchise Law General Liquor Law Mergers & Acquisitions Public Utilities Real Estate Tax
    Blogs > Biz Law Blog > Does Attorney-Client or Work-Product Privilege...
    Norris McLaughlin, P.A.
    Visit Profile

    Does Attorney-Client or Work-Product Privilege Apply to Your Corporate Client’s Employees?

    What is privileged when you have to interview your corporate client’s CEO, or a security guard, or a manager, or even former employees? Does the attorney-client privilege apply to your interview? Is the employee your client? Does the work-product privilege apply?

    About the Case

    There are commonly occurring questions that were addressed in a recent Pennsylvania Superior Court decision in the case of Newsuan v. Republic Services. The Court’s opinion gives us some guidance on the questions raised above, although the decision has come under some criticism.

    In Newsuan, Republic Services retained counsel to defend it against Plaintiff’s claims. Counsel conducted interviews of 9 current employees and 3 former employees of Republic Services.  Counsel took notes during these interviews. After the interviews were over, counsel offered to represent each of the employees/former employees for the purposes of a deposition.

    Counsel for Republic Services refused to give up any information about the 12 interviewed employees, claiming that the employees were now his clients, thus precluding any ex parte interviews of them by the plaintiff’s counsel.

    The trial court held that corporate counsel had not effectively established an attorney-client relationship with any of the 12 witnesses. The court rejected all claims of attorney-client privilege and work-product privilege.  It ordered the production of counsel’s interview notes and other communications with the witnesses.

    It is essential for corporate counsel to remember that his or her client is not the witness sitting in front of them during an interview, but rather, the client is the corporate entity. Corporate counsel cannot represent both the corporate client and the individual employees unless he or she obtains knowing waivers of any potential conflicts between the corporation and the employees, such that counsel can jointly represent both.

    In reversing the lower court in Newsuan, the Superior Court held that corporate counsel had not effectively established an attorney-client relationship with the 12 current or former employees, and thus attorney-client privilege did not apply. The Court did say, however, the interviews of the 12 current and former employees were protected by the attorney-client privilege arising between corporate counsel and Republic Services because with both current and former employees’ communications about worksite conditions would be helpful to corporate counsel in providing legal advice to Republic Services.

    Finally, the Superior Court concluded that the work product privilege protected corporate counsel’s notes of the interviews, although counsel would have to identify the witnesses and the plaintiff’s counsel would be permitted to perform ex parte interviews.

    Conclusion

    The extension of the corporate privilege to interviews with former employees appears to be an extension of existing Pennsylvania law, even though the Court made such a holding without citation to any Pennsylvania authority, and the holding actually appeared only in a footnote within the opinion.

    Further, the fact that the Superior Court ruled that the plaintiff’s counsel could perform ex parte interviews of both former and current employees of Republic Services seems to run afoul of Rule of Professional Conduct 4.2. At least one commentator has criticized the Newsuan opinion as “significantly flawed” on the issues of privilege.  Nevertheless, unless this case is reversed on further appeal or otherwise overruled at a later date, the decision provides our latest and best advice on solving the problem of privilege when interviewing a corporate client’s employees.

    If you have any questions about this post or any other related matters, please email the Business Law Practice Group Co-Chairs, David Blatteis at dsblatteis@norris-law.com, Dolores Laputka at dlaputka@norris-law.com, or Graham Simmons at gsimmons@norris-law.com.

    Norris McLaughlin, P.A.
    Visit Profile

    Share

    Tags

    #attorney-client privilege #work-product privilege

    Similar Posts

    November 7, 2022
    Not Ship Shape: SEC Sues Retired Chief Petty Officer for Fraudulent Offerings to Navy-Related Victims
    Not Ship Shape: SEC Sues Retired Chief Petty Officer for Fraudulent Offerings to Navy-Related Victims
    October 13, 2022
    Lessons from an Elder Abuse Story with a (Relatively) Happy Ending
    Lessons from an Elder Abuse Story with a (Relatively) Happy Ending
    August 29, 2022
    Armored to the Brink: SEC Finds Security Company’s Confidentiality Agreement Illegal
    Armored to the Brink: SEC Finds Security Company’s Confidentiality Agreement Illegal

    Helpful links

    • About Us
    • News
    • Services
    • Blogs
    • Attorneys
    • Articles
    • (COVID-19)
    • Events
    • Join our Team
    Connect

    Connect with Us

    • LinkedIn
    • Facebook
    • Twitter
    • Instagram
    • Youtube

    Join our growing team

    We are looking for quality attorneys to help us do more for our clients. At Norris McLaughlin, each attorney has the same opportunity to succeed whether you’re at the beginning of a career or pinnacle of the profession.

    Learn More

    Subscribe to our content

    Receive timely legal information delivered to your inbox

    This field is for validation purposes and should be left unchanged.
    © , Norris McLaughlin, P.A., All Rights Reserved. Attorney Advertising.
    VIEW OUR DISCLAIMER,  TERMS OF USE,  AND PRIVACY POLICY

    We use cookies to ensure that we give you the best experience on our website. If you continue to use this site we will assume you consent to our cookie policy. Learn more